Key findings
- 1Single-ingredient almond butter (just almonds) is as simple as a spread gets; the grinding process is purely mechanical
- 2In our analysis, almond butter averages a Processing Score of 2.6, which is Level 2
- 3Natural oil separation is actually a quality indicator showing no palm oil or hydrogenated stabilizers were added
- 4Almonds are approximately 50% fat by weight, which is why they naturally form a butter when ground, with no added oils needed
Why is Almond Butter Level 2 on average?
At its simplest, almond butter is one ingredient: almonds ground into a paste. Commercial nut grinders apply friction that generates heat, which softens the cell walls and releases the almonds' natural oils, creating a smooth butter. No emulsifiers are needed; the almond's own oil (~50% fat by weight) acts as the binding medium. Some manufacturers add palm oil to prevent the natural oil from separating and rising to the top of the jar. This is a texture convenience, not a necessity; stirring a natural almond butter reincorporates the oil. Sugar and salt additions are flavor-driven. The difference between a one-ingredient almond butter and a heavily formulated one is entirely in the ingredient list, not the grinding process itself. In our analysis, almond butter averages a Processing Score of 2.6, which is Level 2.
How 731 almond butter products break down
Share of products at each processing level, in our analysis.
Almond Butter brand comparison
From least to most processed in our database.
How to read a almond butter label
- 1
The simplest almond butter lists one ingredient: almonds (or "roasted almonds")
- 2
Oil separation at the top of the jar is normal and indicates no added stabilizers
- 3
Palm oil prevents separation but adds a processed ingredient that stir-and-serve jars do without
- 4
Added sugar adds processing; check the ingredient list, not just the front label
Ketzal for iPhone
Got Almond Butter At Home?
Scan yours in Ketzal to see how your exact product scores, not just the average, plus a less processed swap.
Scan It Free
Frequently asked questions
Is almond butter healthier than peanut butter?
From a processing standpoint, both are equivalent when comparing single-ingredient versions (just nuts, maybe salt). The health comparison is nutritional, not processing-related.
Why does natural almond butter separate?
Almond oil is lighter than the ground almond solids and naturally rises to the top over time. This is gravity, not a defect. Stirring reincorporates the oil. Brands that don't separate use added palm oil or hydrogenated oils as stabilizers.
Is store-bought almond butter as good as homemade?
Single-ingredient store-bought almond butter is identical to homemade, and both are just ground almonds. The processing (grinding) is the same. Brands with added palm oil, sugar, or salt are slightly more processed.