beef stick: beef, salt, water, contains less than 2% of: corn syrup, dextrose, natural smoke flavor, spices, hydrolyzed soy protein, natural flavor, sodium erythorbate, lactic acid starter culture, sodium nitrite. pasteurized process cheddar cheese food stick: pasteurized process cheddar cheese food [cultured pasteurized milk, water, sodium phosphate, salt, natural flavoring, sorbic acid, color